Talk Academia

a question to those who resubmitted after getting the Seal of Excellence : did you mention it in your CV? if so, did you get the funding? I scored 88 this year and I want to apply again in September but hesitate whether to mention SoE. I wonder how the reviewers regard this fact, as an achievement ...

a question to those who resubmitted after getting the Seal of Excellence : did you mention it in your CV? if so, did you get the funding? I scored 88 this year and I want to apply again in September but hesitate whether to mention SoE. I wonder how the reviewers regard this fact, as an achievement o...

got my rejection email this morning, 4.2/4.6/4.7 , overall score as given by Dreamer (thanks again!), CAR panel. I got very few comments, nothing helpful. Excellence part - minor remarks, about the secondment hosts. Part 2 and 3 - no weaknesses, so no justification why not 5 and 5. Looks like they ...

got my rejection email this morning, 4.2/4.6/4.7 , overall score as given by Dreamer (thanks again!), CAR panel. I got very few comments, nothing helpful. Excellence part - minor remarks, about the secondment hosts. Part 2 and 3 - no weaknesses, so no justification why not 5 and 5. Looks like they p...

I believe there are no such people, otherwise, somebody would post anything. I also think that rejected people would post here. There were several rejections in the afternoon, and people were discussing reviewers etc. So my guess is that everything just stopped. my score is 88.2 (from Dreamer, many ...

as I also understood that I'm rejected, asked Dreamer (many thanks!) got 88.2 in CAR panel, rejected. Note that last year I was below threshold with the very same project. I sent it unchanged just because I know it is good and the reviewers' comments were unhelpful and ridiculous. And well, it seem...

as I also understood that I'm rejected, asked Dreamer (many thanks!) got 88.2 in CAR panel, rejected. Note that last year I was below threshold with the very same project. I sent it unchanged just because I know it is good and the reviewers' comments were unhelpful and ridiculous. And well, it seem...

as I also understood that I'm rejected, asked Dreamer (many thanks!) got 88.2 in CAR panel, rejected. Note that last year I was below threshold with the very same project. I sent it unchanged just because I know it is good and the reviewers' comments were unhelpful and ridiculous. And well, it seems...

Just received the rejection e-mail. Evaluation seems pretty, pretty fair. They raised points that were really something I worried about in the excellence part, but some others I was not expecting in implementation. Very good. Will talk to my supervisors and prepare for the next call. Wish the best ...

if EC really wanted to prevent leaks, they wouldn't have sent the info to NCPs in advance!
actually, I still don't understand why they do it but it was a relief to many, especially the birthday guy NoPanic