Talk Academia

Rejection - 81.6% (EF-ENV).

Some of the weaknesses listed under implementation are contradicted by statements on strength under excellence. Oh well, time to go to sleep.

Congratulations and commiserations to everyone.

Tingting wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 2:19 am

SOC just received the result, 92. 6. In reserve list…Guys pray for me.

Well done! Email your NCP tomorrow and see where in the list you are, you never know!!

flight75 wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 2:22 am

Just a got a positive result 95%

Yesss! Congratulations!

Rejection letter received. SOC - Magic Link: Evaluation - Score (really low): 55.80% Note that this time I had gone through training (by the host) and the proposal was reviewed by 4 academics, and 3 time by the local Horizon office. Last time, two years ago, a very similar proposal got 74, without ...

Rejection SOC here. Score went down from 88.2 to 86. Impact went down to almost perfect with no comments (4.9) to 4.1. Well, I already complained a lot about the reviewers, so that is it. Good luck everyone! That sucks, sorry! Did you get any reasons as to why you got 4.1 for impact this time? Two ...

beymsca wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 1:32 am

Another rejection here.

EF-LIF, score 92.20

Good luck everyone!

So unlucky! The cut off must be incredibly high for the LIF panel.

Fu Manchu wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 1:27 am

Rejection SOC here.

Score went down from 88.2 to 86.

Impact went down to almost perfect with no comments (4.9) to 4.1.

Well, I already complained a lot about the reviewers, so that is it. Good luck everyone!

That sucks, sorry! Did you get any reasons as to why you got 4.1 for impact this time?

Sorry to UKR and Taha2021, I hope you at least get some good feedback. I'm sorry to hear that Taha2021... Maybe they are sending rejection letters first due to last year complaints? I'm still in Evaluation, so much likely rejected, but nothing yet. So they'd only send rejection letters to >70%? They...

I'm sure they won't have overcome the enormous technical challenge of sending 8000 simultaneous emails by Monday ( :roll: ), probably will be a rolling release over a few days. For what I've gathered from that article posted some pages back is that EC notify successful/reserve list first. They said...

I don't think it's particularly strange to wonder about what the net salary is. I don't know what my results are, but if I don't get the Marie Curie then I intend to apply for a Humboldt Fellowship (as I want to work with a particular supervisor in Germany), so I'm curious what my net salary might b...