Talk Academia

I will be so happy if any of winners can send me their section about 'Magnitude & importance of the project’s contribution to expected scientific, societal, & economic impacts' from private. This is the only reason why I am not funded and wondering what I did wrong.. I can also send you mine. Did n...

Last year I got 83, my implementation part receive 3.4, this year I got 75, I have not made any major changes to the other parts, just concentrated on the implementation, and implementation was 2.5! excellence dropped from 4.6 to 3.4! The number of months and the budget were wron, and the reviewers...

I got 92.2 and rejected in GF ENV. Ok the score is very high...but I cannot totally understand the evaluation. e.g. implementation: lots of strength point and the last one states: "The host institutions will provide access to high-quality infrastructure and facilities and fieldwork opportunities". ...

Yeah, I do not understand how the "weakness" comments relate to the grade. It just seems that they count the number of comments made in the "strength" section and compare it to the number made in the "weakness" section and attribute a grade? In my evaluation report, comments made in the "strength" s...

What? My application was rejected on a technicality: "Researcher does not comply with the mobility rule: they have resided or carried out their main activity (work, studies, etc.) in the country of the beneficiary for more than 12 months in the 36 months immediately before the call deadline" Howeve...

Does anybody know if it is possible to claim another revision? I am devasted. Last year I get 91.4%. I have improved my proposal and everything in my evaluation is good. Only few points of weakness very absurds. I have recieved 71% this year with the improved proposal. Without the Seal of excellent...

Hi guys, IF-ENV here, got 77.9 this year, got 90.1 last time for the exact same project. The reviewers' comments had been taken into consideration and the whole thing had been polished ... My rating has dropped drastically for the Excellence part; I have more comments in strengths, but also in weakn...