Talk Academia

What happened with this case in the end and, the redress impedes you on getting the Seal of Excellence or only the redress successful cases don't get the SOE?

I don't have the Seal of Excellence and I got 91%.... what does this mean?

When are we gonna receive the SOE certificates?

Whe rejected do you get an evaluation, score? something?

I am thinking to apply this year but I have NO IDEA how to do so. My panel should be Life Sciences: how relevant is to have a CNS paper first author?- I have a NCB paper first author from my postdoc and a Mol Cell first author review (plus others from the PhD less relevant), but I heard from some pe...

Nothing because SOE by itself already does not mean anything

perception matters. If you think more than 38% of the proposals eventually got more than 85%, is it really a distinction? in Universities scoring above some % is called distinction, irrespective of how many got that score. its same as this, i feel. But however, my point of saying "perception matter...

Hi there, I have experience with redress, in a situation more or less like yours so here are my hints: it takes about three months to have a feedback and unless your claim is something obviously wrong, they will not accept it. What i heard is that they need to make a real evident error, like mentio...

Hi all I will also request for redress. My case 1st attempt got 91.2 CHE, and the cut-off was 91.8, left out with 0.6,and U.K didn't joined horizon as well in 2023. 2nd attempt, addressed the comments only 2-3, and submitted again, got below 60, I have no idea, which hater checked my proposal, and ...

EF-PHY 91% not funded 4.3/4.8/4.8 There is essentially a single weakness listed in excellence, yet only 4.3 score. Any experiences whether it is worth to appeal? My case is also one that I am debating if I should complain or not; 3.9 in the implementation fucked up all my application, almost perfec...