Talk Academia

The link is not working. I assume they may start changing the status into ranking if we take the link still valid.

I think this year they may have changed the strategy. Instead of EVALUATION phase they kept all at SUBMISSION and only changed now into EVALUATION which could imply RANKING. This is my assumption, of course.

This is a very good observation. I had the same thoughts on this

evolved wrote: ↑

Thu Jan 24, 2019 8:58 pm

something very annoying and non transparent is that they dont share the 3 reviewer scores in the evaluation reports. Why? where is the breakdown of the score? to see how they reached the final decision.

Mine also just changed into EVALUATION

It seems the link is actually working. Just that they may have left uploads for the last days.

I expect not earlier than 28th (perhaps they start in thr night of 27th), judging from the experience of last year.

This could be the case because unlike last year, this year only one links work (the “outdated” one) and even that is like a freezed link with only SUBMISSION remaining. quote=megasphaera post_id=2829 time=1547481146 user_id=328] At this stage, I think results are going to be delayed, unless they are...

Folks,

The link with ...outdated project is working but not the other one. Is that the case with you? In mine outdates link it still stands SUBMISSION.

Some of the links does not contain the real info. In my case, it is the info of my application, not the modified panel. So the status remained the same and I beleive this is the case with most of us. Lets share tomorrow the results and see whether these links were accurate. I am not sure this is goi...

The thing is how we ensure that the links tell us whether we are ranked or not?
At least some of us having different info from the real ones.

Well my panel changed from IF_SOC into SE_SOC since October and the link indicating EVALUATION is since then while actually in the "frozen" link it says IF panel whereas in the sealed document and other platforms it says it is SE. So this EVALUATION and RANKING does not seem to be accurate to me. Th...