Talk Academia

Baka mitai wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 2:53 am

Rejected. From 85.4, to 84.6....... to 61.

..well, I'm so done with academia. Thank you all for your support, and good luck for the rest !

Jesus, this is so f#$& up.

Good luck with your next steps!

That sucks, sorry! Did you get any reasons as to why you got 4.1 for impact this time? Two comments. One about my future career that is not well developed and other that I was not convincing enough about the impact in a specific thing. I addressed a few aspects on both, but they want something "con...

Rejection SOC here. Score went down from 88.2 to 86. Impact went down to almost perfect with no comments (4.9) to 4.1. Well, I already complained a lot about the reviewers, so that is it. Good luck everyone! That sucks, sorry! Did you get any reasons as to why you got 4.1 for impact this time? Two ...

Rejection SOC here.

Score went down from 88.2 to 86.

Impact went down to almost perfect with no comments (4.9) to 4.1.

Well, I already complained a lot about the reviewers, so that is it. Good luck everyone!

alherpo wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:30 am

I'm sorry to hear that Taha2021...

Maybe they are sending rejection letters first due to last year complaints?

Oh, I didnt see this post before.

I had the same feeling, but lets wait a bit more to actually know if this is true.

Nothing here so far.

Did anyone who got funded receive the email? Perhaps, after all the complaining from last year's results, they are sending the rejections first.

Checking the table that we are building together I realized that someone with my same panel (CHE), same type of fellowship (GF) and first letter of acronym very close to mine (S vs P) went to ranking the 1st of march while I went to ranking on the 2nd. This seems to invalidate the theories of acron...

MSCA_SOC_2019 wrote: ↑

Thu Mar 17, 2022 2:11 pm

Guys,

I come back just to stop your speculations
Switzerland was not part of the MSCA 2021 call! It is why they have their own call... We discussed that before!

Yes!

As an example, I tried both fellowships (MSCA with a Belgium host and the SNSF/Horizon with a Swiss one).

Based on number reported here, the changes to ranking on first march happened only up to 4 pm and after that the change in phase was not reported. Then, started next morning around nine. It is possible that all winners changed on first march and the rest on second march. I really hope that you are ...

So, the prediction is next week then. Let's suffer for another week. In the meantime, I am exploring other options for a fellowship in the case my application is not successful and I remember that you guys were talking about the Swiss equivalence of MSCA - SNFS. Do you have any idea when they will ...