Talk Academia

Ugh, via a leak also dropped below threshold. Submission #1 = seal of excellence & waitlist etc, submission #2, rejection, but strong scores on everything but excellence and still over 80, submission #3 below threshold and I’m sure it is because I addressed the reviewer critique from last year. My ...

In case that happens, do you know whether is worthy to appeal? How is it possible that they give you the seal off excellence one year and the next one leave you below threshold? How then other agencies will find a proposal they recommend if they do not do??? You can only appeal on technical grounds.

I’m out and below 70. Evaluation stage doesn’t bode well.

Ugh!

Sorry my resubmission friends, I know how rough this is.

Ugh, via a leak also dropped below threshold. Submission #1 = seal of excellence & waitlist etc, submission #2, rejection, but strong scores on everything but excellence and still over 80, submission #3 below threshold and I’m sure it is because I addressed the reviewer critique from last year. My a...

They have arrested it for revealing that the results are out :ugeek: :lol: This is a good one!!! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: We know the NCPs have results in advance because Dreamer had them last year. So Monday Dreamer gets lucky and/or other NCPs tell you. Then Tuesday you get the email. Three days m...

I think Dreamer said this is the same pattern as last year. Friday, results get emailed to NCP. Monday NCP gives to Dreamer. Tuesday official emails arrive. But last year mail came on Feb 4. I don't think they will start sending very close to deadline. what was the deadline for last year ? The 11th...

goshgoshgosh wrote: ↑

Fri Feb 05, 2021 10:23 pm

how crazy that the results are out and nobody leaked them already!

I think Dreamer said this is the same pattern as last year. Friday, results get emailed to NCP. Monday NCP gives to Dreamer. Tuesday official emails arrive.

The best we can hope for is midnight Sunday. But we will all be drunk from NoPanic42’s birthday celebrations, so it’ll be fine. Or we will be sad and hungover AND rejected on Monday.

Woohoo, 4pm UK time on Sunday is 11am in the US. But for sure I will join the party early NoPanic42; it's like the last fun before knowing that you actually failed. So NCPs have the results *could* mean that they start being sent at midnight Bruxelles time Sunday so that people get them throughout t...

Ooh, education science is cool! 😎 Let’s hope that CAR is just wonky somehow this year, or the whole system. I am finding it hard to think that we have so many with precocious good scores who would go <70. We have a glimpse of a back-end process, so we do g really know what is happening. For sure, t...