Talk Academia

The forum at its best lmao :lol: :lol: :lol: And in specific details what do you say: a table, a chair, some office space, a computer, printer, scanner, pens, paper, and you put your shopping list there to reach sufficient detail ... :lol: Also you need to specify you have access to a toilet. Just ...

And in specific details what do you say: a table, a chair, some office space, a computer, printer, scanner, pens, paper, and you put your shopping list there to reach sufficient detail ... I think this is really exaggerated from the reviewers side. At this level and for this money this kind of infr...

I think this is really exaggerated from the reviewers side. At this level and for this money this kind of infrastructure details shouldn't be a topic of discussion. Let's be serious, everyone will get an office space and a computer, noone will write her/his articles on the floor and conduct the res...

some of the criticisms were fair, but some were way off mark - the proposal has been fine-tuned every year based on feedback and yet received a progressively lower score - last time 86%, so it really does depend on the reviewer :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry: As someone said before, they might be biased wh...

I am curious as to whether you thought the reviews were fair in each case? Last year I got pretty good reviews, but only made the reserve list. I know that they were looking for the minor points to criticize. So I am curious to see what comes out this year - I know my application is good, but I cou...

PS Excellence has scored well, always 4++ but altogether not hitting the 96% region ..so close and yet so far.... :roll: :roll: :roll: :roll: I am curious as to whether you thought the reviews were fair in each case? Last year I got pretty good reviews, but only made the reserve list. I know that t...

The flip side is that whatever is NOT in your proposal can be turned into a weakness by the reviewers. I have seen a dozen reviewer reports and the most common comment is "this and that has not been elaborated enough" or worse, "the applicant COULD HAVE elaborated on their foreign language competen...

Loved it!! The place and the people. Such a nice feeling being there. My penpal since childhood (!) is from there. I went to Dublin for work and we managed to meet for the very first time!! That's where I'm from! I actually just booked our one-way tickets back to Dublin this morning, so I'm looking...

First time it took me ages. The host did not helped; I wrote the project and I submitted to different fellowships, so it was revised several times by supervisor and secondments. A friend of mine, msca reviewer, had a deep look into it and gave me few very good advices. NCP also revised it. After fai...

Dear Members, I am in Evaluation Phase. is there any chance for getting fellowship? unlikely That's what you said to another user. So it's not what kind of info you want to believe from the link. You clearly said to another user, with your fragmented piece of info, that he will unlikely get it. Aga...