2018 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2018)

[evolved]

there are three possibilities:

1. people that remain in evaluation and go into ranking late are winners.
2. people that remain in evaluation and don’t go into ranking are in the <70% threshold.
3. evaluation and ranking depend on ID and panel, and do not predict anything.

pick your favorite explanation that will help you sleep tonight

[Bren]

Defo agree on this.

By the way there is no relation whoever goes to ranking first and winning proposal.It is just random.What we know is results will be out shortly

[msca2018]

839XXX - Ranking

[xman25]

there are three possibilities:

1. people that remain in evaluation go into ranking late are winners.
2. people that remain in evaluation and don’t go into ranking are in the <70% threshold.
3. evaluation and ranking depend on ID and panel, and do not predict anything.

pick your favorite explanation that will help you sleep tonight

Obviously I will choose 1
Declaration of interest: still in evaluation

[megasphaera]

That's for sure. We have no idea, so please do not stress yourself and most importantly do not stress the others!

Defo agree on this.

By the way there is no relation whoever goes to ranking first and winning proposal.It is just random.What we know is results will be out shortly

[evolved]

Unfortunately the percentages of people <70% and that get the funding are more or less very similar ~10-20%.
So all scenarios "fit".

[IF ST LIF]

there are three possibilities:

1. people that remain in evaluation and go into ranking late are winners.
2. people that remain in evaluation and don’t go into ranking are in the <70% threshold.
3. evaluation and ranking depend on ID and panel, and do not predict anything.

pick your favorite explanation that will help you sleep tonight

Options 1 and 2 happened last year. You never know. Although this year they might have changed the way that the system encodes everything in the database...

[Bren]

Am I the only one who thinks its weird that this link even exists? Bit of a messed up way to follow the progression of ones evaluation...

[hmdoel]

I think it is not a good idea to join or read this forum if you anyone doesnt want to feel stress

a right amount of stress can be fun sometimes

That's for sure. We have no idea, so please do not stress yourself and most importantly do not stress the others!

Defo agree on this.

By the way there is no relation whoever goes to ranking first and winning proposal.It is just random.What we know is results will be out shortly

[amannu]

evolved wrote: ↑Tue Jan 29, 2019 4:13 pm
there are three possibilities:

1. people that remain in evaluation and go into ranking late are winners.
2. people that remain in evaluation and don’t go into ranking are in the <70% threshold.
3. evaluation and ranking depend on ID and panel, and do not predict anything.

pick your favorite explanation that will help you sleep tonight

I am still on evaluation but I am sure to be over the threshold, so I woul exclude the option 2