2019 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2019)

[Kenniz]

SOC Panel

Wow, your score is exactly the same as last year's cut-off for the SOC panel. Fingers crossed you're close enough to have a chance at getting the grant after all.

https://ec.europa.eu/research/participa ... les_en.pdf

What happens to those on the reserve list? What are their chances?

basically extremely low, the first 1-3 could get in, the rest not.

[SaraD]

So painful!

Wow, your score is exactly the same as last year's cut-off for the SOC panel. Fingers crossed you're close enough to have a chance at getting the grant after all.

https://ec.europa.eu/research/participa ... les_en.pdf

What happens to those on the reserve list? What are their chances?

basically extremely low, the first 1-3 could get in, the rest not.

[AnnaMC]

kitten?

PS: Congrats to those who got it! It's a big deal. To the rest of us, keep trying and keep living! Don't fall, failures and rejections are part of life. This is how we improve. This is how we learn. This is how we finally succeed.

Yeah, but now I am in that group where the resubmitted proposal (which was undoubtedly better) dropped in score significantly from the previous year. I am now waiting for the comments to try and figure out what they claim is wrong. I am really struggling with this.

Wait and see the evaluation report. I think what you experience is very painful, and it proves that the evaluation process is highly subjective if not profoundly questionable. You can manage this- this is how academia, and, supposedly, the peer-review process, works. I am personally considering a third submission just because I received a slightly better score than last year (86,4% as compared to 83%, although I also think that the proposal was vastly improved), and, honestly, next time after what I read and see here and not just here, I would expect any type of result. But that would be the last time I go through this. These applications require so much work. I prefer spending my time wisely and commiting to something else, not a roulette game... Again congrats to the roulette winners! But don't fall because of this. Not worth your sadness and frustration.

[Dreamer]

Guys my private inbox is full. I am sorry I must stop with answers. I must work today.

Just wait for your results. Fucking lazy NCP already knows all results.

[Kenniz]

So painful!

What happens to those on the reserve list? What are their chances?

basically extremely low, the first 1-3 could get in, the rest not.

it is. but you have to remember you only get in from reserve if something happens to the one on main list that leads to not taking the fellowship. this will probably not happen regularly at all. maybe 1 per list or so on average

[Dreamer]

Guys I do not have yours evaluation report.It is not normal that I have that.

[jmk12]

Here we go... Lord Dreamer just sent me a reply:

"93.2
main list"

Does that mean that I got it? Oh my... I sure as hell hope that his information is correct, if it is indeed so...

main list means you got it. what is your panel? 93.2 is really close to cutoff and for lif it would be reserve only last year

Chemistwy

[Shapovalov]

Guys my private inbox is full. I am sorry I must stop with answers. I must work today.

Just wait for your results. Fucking lazy NCP already knows all results.

No worries.
Since the NCPs don't want to be overwhelmed with requests, now everyone is overwhelming you.

All the best for your future applications!

[Wiggo]

Guys my private inbox is full. I am sorry I must stop with answers. I must work today.

Just wait for your results. Fucking lazy NCP already knows all results.

Thanks again for your help!

[Kenniz]

Future Generations of Applicants in this forum will remember Dreamer and tell stories of his legacy ...