2020 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2020)

[byo001]

Just received the rejection e-mail.

Evaluation seems pretty, pretty fair. They raised points that were really something I worried about in the excellence part, but some others I was not expecting in implementation.

Very good. Will talk to my supervisors and prepare for the next call.

Wish the best for you, guys!

Which panel?

[robust_and_resilient]

Just received the rejection e-mail.

Evaluation seems pretty, pretty fair. They raised points that were really something I worried about in the excellence part, but some others I was not expecting in implementation.

Very good. Will talk to my supervisors and prepare for the next call.

Wish the best for you, guys!

Which panel?

and which score? close to cutoff?
sorry, and good luck next time!

[mzach]

Just received the rejection e-mail.

Evaluation seems pretty, pretty fair. They raised points that were really something I worried about in the excellence part, but some others I was not expecting in implementation.

Very good. Will talk to my supervisors and prepare for the next call.

Wish the best for you, guys!

You are probably the first one !

[Interstellar]

It is just a grant announcement -- relax, how on earth would it be a crime!

If knowing the results in advance from a leak you had nothing to do with is a crime, then so is announcing on twitter that the results are out when they aren't. Now that's a crime.

Yes, agreed. The NCP was being kind and the DreamTeam were super generous with their crime. Versus the MSCA folks who have consigned those who didn’t get the grant to just having to sit and wait.

Wait...i don't tell nothing about the dream team or the people who ask...but say that this is not legal...for the rest....no problem

[HopefullyMCIF]

If knowing the results in advance from a leak you had nothing to do with is a crime, then so is announcing on twitter that the results are out when they aren't. Now that's a crime.

Yes, agreed. The NCP was being kind and the DreamTeam were super generous with their crime. Versus the MSCA folks who have consigned those who didn’t get the grant to just having to sit and wait.

Wait...i don't tell nothing about the dream team or the people who ask...but say that this is not legal...for the rest....no problem

.... the only thing we need to say about DreamTeam is: "Thank you"

[no42]

It is just a grant announcement -- relax, how on earth would it be a crime!

If knowing the results in advance from a leak you had nothing to do with is a crime, then so is announcing on twitter that the results are out when they aren't. Now that's a crime.

Yes, agreed. The NCP was being kind and the DreamTeam were super generous with their crime. Versus the MSCA folks who have consigned those who didn’t get the grant to just having to sit and wait.

Look, some people making noise about this on twitter is one. But, on what basis do you establish an illegality ? First off its not blatant plagiarism. Second, as someone point out EC made a big mess. They shouldn't have revealed it to the NCP, if at all and NCP to the applicants. If knowing results before an official emails is seen is a crime, then congratulations you've are the first time traveler and just gone back in time to medieval era. If at all, the DreamerTeam made some applicants feel comfortable.

[wait_for_w8...]

SE-PHY here, and I doubt they send them by ranking. I got 97.8 and received the first email at 11:40 Brussels time. That's 6 to 7 hours later than you, but we were in a different panel. People ranked below me in SE-PHY also got emails earlier. My grant ID is 10102XXXX, but I think it's also confirmed that it doesn't go by ID number (creation time of application).

However, I could download my ESR already at 11:00. Weird that it takes 40 min to send an email after uploading the files.

Do they publish the results in alphabetical order? I mean, surname of the applicant ...
Can someone confirm this theory?

I believe they send emails based on ranking. I got 98.4 and got the mail 6 hours ago.

Interesting. I guess glitches in the system are possible. I just made the statement based on the observation that everyone who got the grant also got the email and announced it here. But certainly I would not be too keen to happy to announce that I did not get it. It can be hard to swallow.

[Capone]

So I gave up and asked Dreamer. 93.4 in ST-LIF. Failed. This was my only chance because now I've been living for over a year in the host country. It's a pity because I got so close. Anyways, thanks to Dreamer for being so kind and helpful! And for the ones that got it, congrats!!

[cbmoura]

Just received the rejection e-mail.

Evaluation seems pretty, pretty fair. They raised points that were really something I worried about in the excellence part, but some others I was not expecting in implementation.

Very good. Will talk to my supervisors and prepare for the next call.

Wish the best for you, guys!

Which panel?

and which score? close to cutoff?
sorry, and good luck next time!

SOC Panel, Score: 76,4. Thank you for your support, guys!

[wait_for_w8...]

Hey dude! Relax! Go to the EC and report me, at the same time tell them to send out the rejection letters!

It is just a grant announcement -- relax, how on earth would it be a crime!

If knowing the results in advance from a leak you had nothing to do with is a crime, then so is announcing on twitter that the results are out when they aren't. Now that's a crime.

The worst thing what can happen is that if they find who leaked it, will not be NCP anymore. Thats all I guess.