Talk Academia

I'm sorry guys ....

So sorry to here for the persons received rejection
So far no email for me
All the best for all

We need a positive result to cheer up, I would be so glad if the active members in here can get it!

Till now no email.

alherpo wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:54 am

michelef wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:51 am

Just got the rejection unfortunately...

I'm sorry michelef... It is very difficult to find words to comfort you

When did you move to ranking? Did you get good feedback at least? We are here to read you if you need it

It's ok, thank you...
The change to ranking was somewhere on March 1st.
The evaluation mentioned a lot of strengths, but it seems that the excellence part got a big slash because "the idea is not novel enough"
The usual stuff just seen in many reviews... Only the reviewer knows who already did that...

I should go to sleep, tomorrow morning I have an important meeting, but I just cannot imagine sleeping a wink now

michelef wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:59 am

alherpo wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:54 am

michelef wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:51 am

Just got the rejection unfortunately...

I'm sorry michelef... It is very difficult to find words to comfort you

When did you move to ranking? Did you get good feedback at least? We are here to read you if you need it

It's ok, thank you...
The change to ranking was somewhere on March 1st.
The evaluation mentioned a lot of strengths, but it seems that the excellence part got a big slash because "the idea is not novel enough"
The usual stuff just seen in many reviews... Only the reviewer knows who already did that...

Quite relative again But seal of excellence at least? did your gf get it?

So sorry for you three...

It's okay to feel bad, but if you feel you made something wrong, please try to remember that this letter doesn't mean your project is not good, like we said again and again. You were just unlucky in a grant that requires prodigious amounts of luck.

(well, I know that I will not be able to remember that if/when my project is rejected, but still)

alherpo wrote: ↑

Mon Mar 21, 2022 12:59 am

I should go to sleep, tomorrow morning I have an important meeting, but I just cannot imagine sleeping a wink now

Stay here. Its action time now. Also, I dont want to do this without all who have been together since 1 month

There are close to 150 people on this portal. Any updates anyone?