2021 Marie Curie Postdoctoral Fellowship (HE-MSCA-PF-2021)

[Mar2022]

Rejection EF CHE 76.8

[skm]

hi all,
thanks for this forum sharing sorrows and successes as well.
compared to many others here. just now i got the mail of rejection. and the score is 76.6 for PHY.
Excellence : 3.7
Impact: 4.2
Implementation: 3.6

Lot of things can be learned from the evaluation results, but as experienced by many others in this thread, its essential to rectify them in next application, but not sure of success.

My project is purely theoretical and computational. Not sure even if i improve next time, the project can be given a good credibility.
but anyway, bad day because of unsuccessful result.
May be we should form a small group of 3 to 4 applicants, and prepare their proposals with consultations each other commenting very critically each other for improvement.

above all, i thing the Subject of the project should be very "APT" and should be "NEED OF THE HOUR" type.
what do you all say?

[FairEnough]

Type of Action: HORIZON-TMA-MSCA-PF-EF-CHE"
title: Information Letter for reserve list
Score: 91.4% (4.4/5.0/4.3)
Reserve list.
I don't know how luckily I'll get it or not, however, life will never stop for this call!!

Cheers and enjoy guys. Allah SWT (God) is the best planner. Remain positive, please!!

[apdodo]

Rejection EF CHE 76.8

Hi guys, do you think the majority of results declared until now is unsuccessful ones although given the number of applicants, obviously we expect to hear more unsuccessful than successful results?

[Wolvy_18]

90.8.. reserve list.. CHE panel... Any idea what was the CHE cut off?

[AnthroMSCA]

Just got a rejection with a score of 75 (SOC-EF). Last year, it was 90.8. Not many changes were made to the proposal. I have addressed only the 'limitations' suggested by the reviewers. So luck seems to be an important factor. Good luck to you with the results.

[MC22]

Gf SOC: 69.4, from 88.4: 20 points lower from last year. In Evaluation all the time

[4degrees]

Rejection - 81.6% (EF-ENV).

Some of the weaknesses listed under implementation are contradicted by statements on strength under excellence. Oh well, time to go to sleep.

Congratulations and commiserations to everyone.

[xuc]

EE 99.6: 5/5, 5/5, 4.9/5. Notification Received 12:25 am.

[MC22]

Excellent score! Congratulations to you!