2018 Marie Curie Individual Fellowship (H2020-MSCA-IF-2018)

[expert_pastMC]

you should give it another go, since you have the proposal ready! wait and see what the ESR says.

Ok thank you mate. I have to wait the ESR. That means I am not going to apply again. Review process is ridiculous I believe.

sorry to hear that. you need good grounds to request an evaluation review, like factual errors that you see in the evaluation. But I doubt you could find such, as I think they are super careful with how the evaluators phrase the comments (very generic) so as to avoid such requests. and they are also scrutinised later on by the panels before the evaluation comments are released to the candidates.

I got exactly same score. Only 2 point increased then last year's score. got rejected again. Is there anyway request an evaluation review ?

[Cla]

Sorry for the spanish, it is just about the spanish NCP, nothing interesting
Justo cuando he hablado con él estaba apagando el ordenador para irse.

Estaba llamando a Jesús y ya veo que han puesto el el contestador. probablemente tendríamos k esperar hasta el lunes

Me acaban de contestar que ellos estan sujetos a total confidencialidad y no pueden decir nada.

As usual...

[hmdoel]

for me to be honest, I am not ready to know my score without knowing what's written in ESR

[Aman19]

Ok thank you mate. I have to wait the ESR. That means I am not going to apply again. Review process is ridiculous I believe.

sorry to hear that. you need good grounds to request an evaluation review, like factual errors that you see in the evaluation. But I doubt you could find such, as I think they are super careful with how the evaluators phrase the comments (very generic) so as to avoid such requests. and they are also scrutinised later on by the panels before the evaluation comments are released to the candidates.

I got exactly same score. Only 2 point increased then last year's score. got rejected again. Is there anyway request an evaluation review ?

If your host is not from UK, germany or france, you dont stand a chance, especially in engineering

[xman25]

Funny part is I addressed the "weaknesses". I think they keep finding more

sorry to hear that onwards and upwards

You were alson in Evaluation phase all the time right? Like me

Cheer up mate, lets do it again next year.
I'm also in evaluation all the time.

[AdinaBabesh]

I have the same question.My impression is that the results are not officially out, but only via the NCP. Those who want to tell the results, of course ...

HAS ANYONE GOT THE OFFICIAL EMAIL WITH THE RESULTS OR THOSE WHO KNOW THE RESULTS IS VIA NCP ONLY?

[IF ST LIF]

Sorry for the spanish, it is just about the spanish NCP, nothing interesting
Justo cuando he hablado con él estaba apagando el ordenador para irse.

Estaba llamando a Jesús y ya veo que han puesto el el contestador. probablemente tendríamos k esperar hasta el lunes

Me acaban de contestar que ellos estan sujetos a total confidencialidad y no pueden decir nada.

Last year I tried to have my position in the reserve from them. It was impossible...

[cukovic]

[kassiek]

This has just become terrifying. I’m a bit glad Ireland is staying silent. I would rather just find out officially rather than email in terror.

[sbm]

Buffff.. Viernes a las 15h.

Sorry for the spanish, it is just about the spanish NCP, nothing interesting
Justo cuando he hablado con él estaba apagando el ordenador para irse.

Estaba llamando a Jesús y ya veo que han puesto el el contestador. probablemente tendríamos k esperar hasta el lunes

Me acaban de contestar que ellos estan sujetos a total confidencialidad y no pueden decir nada.